www average-bear
The presidential address
« Word of the day | Main | Ow »

  recent comments
· Julia
· Jackie
· NoelleFrost
· Rey
· NoelleFrost
· czeltic girl
· Rey
· Boulder Dude
· Randal Trimmer
· Randal Trimmer







I know I should never talk about politics on here — I know it never goes well, but here it is.

I’m torn, literally torn right down the middle, about the war in Iraq.

On the one hand, if all I consider is Saddam and the things he’s done, the things he could do… not just (or even mostly) to the U.S. but to his own people, I have no doubt in my mind that taking him out of power is something that any right-thinking person would want to do, if they had the power to do so.

(It doesn’t mean that you’re automatically right-thinking for wanting to do that, just FYI.)

On the other hand, I look at the people who are in power in the government at this time, causing this event to move forward — shoving it down the throats of anyone who disagrees, and I don’t want this.

Is it the right thing to do? Yes. It is at least a right thing to do.

Is it being pushed by the people involved for the right reasons? (or even being pushed for the reasons present in numerous speeches) No. My gut feeling is no.

I think it’s the right thing to do, and at the same time it kills me that Bush Co. is doing it.

Is it alright to do the right thing for the wrong reasons? How about with the wrong leaders?

Falling Down • 09:13 PM, 03.17.03

Comments


That pretty much sums up my feelings, too. I think Saddam needs to be removed from power, but there is too much baggage of oil and family with our current president in office to make it appear as anything other than revenge or greed - I don't really think that is the reason, but clearly many people do and it's understandable.

posted by Xkot, March 17, 2003 11:18 PM

Yep. I think you've hit a note that many will agree with.

Saddam and his tribal cronies are evil. Saddam and his tribal-centric policies are evil. Saddam and his family are just plain evil.

But our nationalistic, anti-terrorism, frat-boy chest-thumping? Er. Possibly not evil, but certainly just plain stupid.

Had we stepped out and protested the mass killings of the Kurdish people, the international community might have backed us up... but we were too busy then with our flush economy and distracted president to worry about the world's woes. ::sigh::

posted by jenn, March 18, 2003 07:43 AM

I hold little truck with Bush's domestic policies, and I run hot and cold on his international performance. But I think dealing militarily with Iraq is the "least worst" foreign policy option at this point, no matter who is at the helm.

posted by *** Dave, March 18, 2003 08:48 AM

I don't like the timing. I don't understand exactly what made it have to happen "now." I don't understand why you have to have war to make peace. I don't know what we've done to rebuild in Afghanistan that we can also do in Iraq if we're successful. I don't like bombing places. I think I'm up to five "I don't"s which means I could be convinced, but I'm not at this point.

posted by MT Fierce, March 18, 2003 11:43 AM

I can relate to how you feel. And I think this website says alot:
www.newamericancentury.org/statementofprinciples.htm
about why this is happening now.

posted by Mary, March 18, 2003 11:55 AM

It's my opinion that all Presidents suck.

Every single one is crappy in one way or another.

I've been alive for some of Nixon, Ford, Carter, Reagan, H.W. Bush, Clinton, G.W. Bush - so you can see where I get my feelings.

Clinton got his job because Perot screwed H.W. Bush, then kept his job because Perot screwed Dole, then G.W. got his job because Florida became the deciding factor in the election and thankt god the Supreme Court took the ball from Florida. From my exposure to Florida and Florida history, chances are some Florida Sugar Cane Baron would have gotten to be President and the Election Committe would have ordered the Everglades drained while the chad counting went on.

Clinton did everything he could to Iraq short of invading in 1998 with Desert Fox, and I personally hold Saddam to be 10 times worse than everything that happened in Kosovo and Bosnia. I don't trust the UN because of thier actions in Somalia and Bosnia.

The world stood by while Rwanda and Central Africa go to pieces and no one charged Vietnam with unilateralism when they dealt the problems in Cambodia, and no one yelled at Tanzania for getting rid of Amin.

I've read a book about the role of the Green Berets in Afghanistan and how much better life was there within weeks of the liberation of that nation, so I don't understand why it's bad for the United States to do what the UN has ordered for 12 years and stop the rape, murder, genocide and ecological crimes of the Iraqi regime?

It'll be bad now for sure, but I always look at Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany as examples of what happens when feet are drug at the geopolitical level.

Sorry, I went long.

posted by Clovis, March 18, 2003 01:40 PM

It's a great day to be a Republican. I'm just glad we are finally going to get this over with. Should have been done a long time ago, but we had that whole disastrous hiccup with Clinton...

You can be good friends with Democrats. You can have them over for dinner. You just don't want them running the country. - Sean Hannity

~Robert

posted by Robert, March 18, 2003 05:23 PM

Robert...

How sad for you...

Clinton was probably one of the best Republicans to hold office in several decades.

And yeah I know, we really don't want Democrats as President. Except for if you want Jobs, a healthe economy, a peaceful trade happy world....(Carter being the exception that proves the rule).

P.S. Hannity is just another talking head idiot...

posted by Boulder Dude, March 18, 2003 05:40 PM

I finding myself wavering even more extremely on the situation, at times given to everything but inaction. we either send weapons to Iraq, because there is an American Charles Foster kane aspect to his lunacy, and not to that of the Saudis (who pose a greater cultural, and economic threat then a marginalized iraq). or we completely restore a tragically lacking element of democracy to the region, even if it is from central casting.
I think there is a healthy heap of ignominy on both sides of the issue. with the europeans and Americans both acting with superiority complexes. I don't think enough real concern for a suffering people has been injected into the debate, and each side cannot be excused from cultural carpet-bagging. This has to be the worst sales job I have seen in american foreign policy in my lifetime.
In my general opinion I must respectfully disagree with the sentiment that political discussions should not appear on blogs. The more substantive a discussion that can be brought forth from the blog community, the more vital it will become. As a general rule I get tired of hearing about the tiny details in peoples lives, and blogs being reality television for the literate.

posted by poppocabba, March 18, 2003 06:20 PM

Want to talk about not finishing the job? Bush 1991. That is all.

posted by Jackie, March 18, 2003 08:02 PM

I feel like "pre-emptive war" is a doctrine that shames America.

I don't feel like Saddam is a threat to America... That was what Afghanistan was about. "Harbor terrorists, refuse to hand them over, and we will re-write your government to better suit our needs." If we're going to re-write their government anyway, where's the incentive?

There are going to be a lot of young Islamic men in the world who think America is unreasonable and inimical after this one. I feel like the war on Iraq is about 170 degrees counter to the war on terrorism.

If we want to create a shining beacon of democracy in the Islamic world, let's work with the country we already have.

I think Doyce has his hand around a hefty chunk of this. Yes, it'd be good if Saddam was gone... But I agree, I don't think we can trust the government right now.

posted by Madeline, March 18, 2003 09:06 PM

Pre-emptive wars in my mind are the same as busting a criminal when they are at the attempted murder stage instead of the aggrivated murder stage.

It's hard to create a democracy in an Islamic state mainly because in Islam, there can be no such thing as seperation of church and state. Turkey works because the military is a beacon of secularism, sometimes to the point of overthrowing an elected government with strong religous ties.

From Cote d'Ivoire to Indonesia there are 56 declared Islamic nations or nations with large Islamic minorities. Of these 56 there is one democracy and three constitutional monarchies or parlimentary democracies with levels of freedom on par with the West.

Turkey, Bangladesh, Malyasia and Indonesia.

Afghanistan will take a long, long time to get where it hopes to be. In the mean time there is regional instability from nations like Iran, Iraq and Saudi Arabia. While rolling over the Saud family and cutting that corner of the world up between Oman, Jordan and the UAE would be an inprovment, that would really inflame the Islamic world. Someday Jordan will retake protectorship of Medina and Mecca from the Sauds, but it can't happen with overt US assistance. The Soviet Union tried to impose Marxist-Stalinist ideals on Afghanistan and we saw how that worked, so the US and UN need to remain there to keep out the Pakistanis and Iranians who like to use Afghanistan for proxy wars against one another, China and the old Soviet 'Stans. Afghanistan will find it's own way now that the Talib and Al Qadea are gone.

Even if the war in Iraq turns the region into a proxy war between the Saudis, Iranians and Turks, at least they won't have time to build nukes or 600 foot guns to shell Europe and Israel...

posted by Clovis, March 18, 2003 10:21 PM

Saddam is "hopefully" gonna be removed from power right? Then by whatever means necessary. I don't care if it means having someone like Jesse Ventura as president, (hell, how about Rush Limbaugh as president!). Just as long as Saddam is gone, I dont' care.

Then come the next election, we'll worry about taking care of our own leaders. Those of us weighing in here, may not want Bush pushing his own agenda. But he is OUR president for now, like it or not.

Right or wrong, we really should support him, for now... and then vote his ass out next year! :)

posted by Big Daddy, March 19, 2003 04:29 AM

The militant Islamicist position is pretty clear: America is the Great Satan and all Islam is properly at jihad with us. Not because of Israel (all the Arab states treat the Palestinians like crap) but because of our culture; America is the anti-Islam. They are also living in a fantasy world where killing 3,000 Americans does anything but piss us off. Saddam has been working for many years to position himself as the number one pan-Islamic leader, with mixed results. He was pretty damned close to producing nukes, he had enough anthrax to kill everyone in the world 5 times over, and who knows what else. He has a history of stupid, megalomaniacal mistakes like invading Kuwait (threatening the oil supply) and starting a war with Iran, which has 5 times Iraq's population. And, of course, he's a genocidal, baby-torturing freak. So let's see: Jihad, megalomania, WMDs, sadistic freak, living in a dream world. No, I don't think we can wait around for a decent and competent president to do this. And who would that be? Gore? Nader? Clinton? Bush I? Reagan? Carter? Ford? Nixon? It's been a long wait since Teddy Roosevelt, dammit.

posted by Randy, March 19, 2003 07:15 AM

I think the last decent President was Ike.

Heck in the last 103 years I'll say - TR, CC, Hoover, FDR, Truman, Ike.

FDR almost doesn't make the list because of some shifty socialist and anti-constitutional things he tried to pull.

Nixon would have made the list if he'd let the Soviets nuke the Chinese nuclear facilities.

posted by Clovis, March 19, 2003 09:22 AM

Ike....Yeesh!

We've been cleaning up his messes for 40 years. Bad, non-personallity general becomes bad non-personallity president

since the last turn of the century I would say TR, Taft, FDR, Truman.

CC, didn't do any thing. Hoover was close to evil.

Give me Progressive's and Socialist's baby!

P.S. I'll through my two cents in with Madeline.

posted by Boulder Dude, March 19, 2003 12:49 PM


©Doyce Testerman. Terms of Use. CCL.